Skip to content
edumaterial.netChange language

Back to French

Correlative variation and the scope of an argument

CEFR C1

What you will learn

  • Build plus… plus and plus… moins while preserving both variables and their direction.
  • Distinguish a graded relationship from a comparison or proven causality.

Before you start

  • Have studied the stated prerequisites and reconstruct who acts before choosing a form.

The idea

Build plus… plus and plus… moins while preserving both variables and their direction.

Plus… plus connects two changes: Plus le dossier s’allonge, plus sa lecture prend du temps. Plus… moins links increase with decrease: Plus le guide est précis, moins les demandes sont ambiguës. Each part has its own subject and predicate; do not turn the second into a simple que complement.

In this construction do not add le before each plus: Plus nous comparons, plus les écarts apparaissent. Le plus normally forms a superlative in a different structure: C’est le plus long dossier. Comparing two objects, Ce dossier est plus long que l’autre, does not describe covariation.

Grammar organises a claim; it proves neither causal mechanism nor universal validity. If the relationship is observed only in this workshop, preserve that scope. Do not turn usually into always or correlation into a guarantee. D’autant plus que reinforces a reason in the existing connector unit; here the new objective is two coordinated changes.

Form and relation

French caseWhat to preserve
Ce dossier est plus long que l’autre.Comparison between two files.
Plus le dossier est long, plus la lecture est lente.Graded relationship between length and reading.

How it sounds

  • Dans cet atelier, plus les consignes sont précises, moins les demandes de clarification sont nombreuses.Precision increases; requests decrease; scope is local.
  • Plus la file s’allonge, plus l’attente augmente.Both variables increase.
Two moments in a workshop: first the table is tidy and one hand is raised; later several hands are raised and materials are scattered.
Observe agents and the relation between scenes; compare them with the written cases.

Build plus… plus and plus… moins while preserving both variables and their direction.

View the illustration

Dans ce service, la précision des formulaires augmente tandis que les demandes de correction diminuent. Quelle phrase conserve les deux variables, leur direction et le lieu d’observation ?

Choose an answer

Answer available without interaction

Answer: Dans ce service, plus les formulaires sont précis, moins les demandes de correction sont nombreuses. — This alternative is appropriate: «Dans ce service, plus les formulaires sont précis, moins les demandes de correction sont nombreuses.». Plus/moins keeps increase/decrease and local scope. Alternatives change the direction of the relationship between the variables.

Plus/moins keeps increase/decrease and local scope. Alternatives change the direction of the relationship between the variables.

Distinguish a graded relationship from a comparison or proven causality.

View the illustration

Le texte dit seulement « Ce rapport est plus long que celui de juin ». Quelle analyse évite d’en tirer une relation non donnée ?

Choose an answer

Answer available without interaction

Answer: Deux rapports sont comparés ; la phrase ne relie pas longueur et nombre d’erreurs. — This alternative is appropriate: «Deux rapports sont comparés ; la phrase ne relie pas longueur et nombre d’erreurs.». Que introduces the second compared object; no errors, changes or purpose are supplied.

Que introduces the second compared object; no errors, changes or purpose are supplied.

When it doesn't hold

What breaks the rule, said out loud. Hiding it is what makes you feel cheated in the exam.

  • Comparison between two files.Ce dossier est plus long que l’autre.
  • Graded relationship between length and reading.Plus le dossier est long, plus la lecture est lente.

What your own language pushes you to say

Wrong Le plus nous relisons, le moins les erreurs restent nombreuses.

Right Plus nous relisons, moins les erreurs restent nombreuses.

English the more uses the; French correlative plus does not use le.

Combine both decisions

Dans ce groupe, quand la préparation devient plus précise, les hésitations deviennent moins nombreuses. Reformulez avec une corrélation, puis nommez une conclusion que ces observations ne permettent pas.

Answer available without interaction
  • The correlation preserves both variables and the direction of their changes.
  • Its scope remains limited to the observed group.
  • Include an unsupported conclusion and explain what evidence would be needed to support it.

Answer: Dans ce groupe, plus la préparation est précise, moins les hésitations sont nombreuses. Cette observation ne prouve pas une causalité et ne garantit pas la même relation dans un autre groupe.

Preserve variables and direction. Reject a guarantee for other groups or proven causality; alternative wording explaining that limit is acceptable.

Curriculum alignment and sources

Continue along this corridor

Practise this: Connectors for formal argumentArgument connectors: guiding the reasoning